Shop Online › "You Pick" Custom 3 pack Image 1 of 5 Image 2 of 5 Image 3 of 5 Image 4 of 5 Image 5 of 5 "You Pick" Custom 3 pack $24.95 Build your own custom 3 pack with our famous Amish Apple Butter™ and Amish Applesauce™ varieties. Custom 1: Select Custom 1 Regular Apple Butter No Added Sugar Apple Butter Regular Apple Sauce Cinnamon Apple Sauce No Added Sugar Apple Sauce Custom 2: Select Custom 2 Regular Apple Butter No Added Sugar Apple Butter Regular Apple Sauce Cinnamon Apple Sauce No Added Sugar Apple Sauce Custom 3: Select Custom 3 Regular Apple Butter No Added Sugar Apple Butter Regular Apple Sauce Cinnamon Apple Sauce No Added Sugar Apple Sauce Quantity: Add To Cart Added! Build your own custom 3 pack with our famous Amish Apple Butter™ and Amish Applesauce™ varieties.